Class representatives and class counsel guide the case, but individual members may have rights to object to a proposed settlement or, in some cases, opt out. A settlement that binds the class requires court approval. Dismissals and judgments may also be appealed, though the available appeal and its effect depend on the decision and applicable deadlines.
How Can a Class Action Lawsuit End Without Recovery?
A proposed class action may end without classwide payments if certification is denied, the case is dismissed, the defendant wins on summary judgment, or the plaintiffs lose at trial or on appeal. Denial of certification alone does not decide the underlying claims; the case may continue on an individual basis.
Some class action lawsuits end in settlement agreements that offer payments, other relief, or both. A court must approve any settlement that would bind the class. If the parties do not settle, the case may proceed to trial, where a judge or jury could rule for the defendant. If a certified class loses on its claims, its members generally will not receive compensation for those claims through that lawsuit.
Do You Have to Pay Money If a Class Action Loses?
Losing a class action does not automatically make class members responsible for the defendant’s fees or damages. Although many class action lawyers work on contingency, the terms of counsel’s agreement do not determine whether the opposing party can recover its costs.
Class members generally are not personally billed if the lawsuit loses. Named plaintiffs may face court costs or, in limited circumstances, the defendant’s fees. Exposure depends on applicable law and any agreements. Members may lose their opportunity to recover through that case.
New cases and investigations, settlement deadlines, and news straight to your inbox.
Can You File an Individual Lawsuit After a Class Action Fails?
Being included in a proposed class does not automatically give up your right to sue individually. If a court certifies the class, a final judgment or approved settlement may bind its members, including people who did not actively participate. Members of certain classes can request exclusion by the deadline. Whether you may bring a separate claim depends on:
- Whether the class was ever certified: Certification can determine whether a class judgment binds unnamed members.
- How the case ended: Denial of certification alone does not decide proposed members’ individual claims.
- Whether the individual opted out: A timely request for exclusion can preserve the right to sue separately when opting out is allowed.
- Whether a judgment or settlement bars the claim: A binding class judgment or approved settlement may prevent a separate lawsuit over covered claims.
- Whether the filing deadline has passed: Applicable tolling may affect the time available to file an individual claim.
- Which jurisdiction’s law applies: The rules governing class actions and later claims can vary by jurisdiction.
What is Tolling?
Tolling pauses or extends a filing deadline. In some federal class actions, the lawsuit pauses the limitations period for individual claims covered by the proposed class while certification is pending. If certification is denied, those individuals may have time to sue separately, but should check their deadlines promptly.
What is Res Judicata?
Under res judicata, a final judgment can prevent people bound by it from litigating the same claim again. If a properly certified class loses on the merits, its members generally cannot sue the defendant again on the same claim. If certification was denied, however, the judgment generally binds only the named parties, not the people they sought to represent. A dismissal without prejudice generally does not bar refiling, while a dismissal with prejudice usually bars those bound by it. Filing deadlines and other legal rules can still affect a later lawsuit.
What Should You Do If a Class Action You Were Part of Fails?
If you were involved in a class action that did not resolve successfully—for instance, if the case was dismissed, certification was denied, or a certified class lost at trial—you may have options for pursuing an individual claim. Take the following steps to understand the outcome and any remaining rights or deadlines.
- Find out exactly how the case ended: Look for the court’s order or final judgment.
- Determine your status: Find out whether you were a named plaintiff, a proposed class member, a certified class member, or someone who requested exclusion from the class.
- Check whether an appeal is pending: An appeal can affect a decision’s finality.
- Check the relevant deadlines: Review limitations periods and any deadlines in court notices.
- Preserve your evidence: Keep relevant records rather than deleting them.
- Speak with an attorney: Seek individualized legal advice to ensure you understand every potential option for seeking accountability and compensation.
When Companies Take Advantage of Consumers, We Can Help
Class Action U’s accomplished partner attorneys at Milberg PLLC have successfully recovered more than $250 million for wronged consumers through alternative dispute resolution.
